Serenity at Oyster Bay

This is the best unit we have ever rented in the area

Our stay at Serenity at Oyster Bay was excellent! The entire home has everything you need for your vacation. The kitchen is fully equipped and the beds are comfortable. It was so nice to wake up with a cup of coffee and sit on the screened porch and listen to nature. We enjoyed the firepit and making smores! We definitely will stay here again. We have been visiting the Island for 28 years and this is the best home we have ever stayed at!

Exactly what we wanted and needed for our stay in Chincoteague. Spacious rooms with all the amenities and even a backyard fire pit.

Had a good stay at this house. The house is very nice, everything was clean and in working order, beds were comfortable, and plenty of eating and cooking utensils provided.

Manager's Response

We loved everthing about our stay at Serenity at Oyster Bay. The house was very clean and in excellent condition!

This house is in a very nice and quiet location. Our only complaint would be that this rental like so many other places we have stayed had a king size bed without a box spring meaning the mattress has no support. As a person who suffers with back issues, I had to sleep in a separate bed from my husband.

This house is in a very nice and quiet location. Our only complaint would be that this rental like so many other places we have stayed had a king size bed without a box spring meaning the mattress has no support. As a person who suffers with back issues, I had to sleep in a separate bed from my husband.

This property couldn't have been more relaxing for our family. The layout was perfect and the house was quiet all while enjoying relaxing views of the canal from the front porch. We will definitely be repeat renters!

Manager's Response

This property couldn't have been more relaxing for our family. The layout was perfect and the house was quiet all while enjoying relaxing views of the canal from the front porch. We will definitely be repeat renters!

Manager's Response

Excellent company to rent from. Property was fantastic for our family.

Manager's Response

I have been coming to the island since the 70’s. Spent my honeymoon there and now some years later, we now bring our grandkids. We started renting a few years back, and have had nothing but pleasant service with Chincoteague Resorts. They are always pleasant whether on the phone or in person. I highly recommend Chincoteague Resorts. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Manager's Response

Second time renting this property. Nice quality furnishings. Clean. Nice screened porch. Large backyard. Fire pit added since last visit. Like outdoor shower and hose availability. Quiet neighborhood.

Manager's Response

The house is cute, secluded enough for us to feel like we're away from it all, and it has all the amenities you could ask for. We were very happy staying here and will absolutely be doing so again.

Manager's Response

The house was sparkling clean and very comfortable (it would be even more comfortable,if the owner replaced the plastic mattress coverings with a nicer material). It is very tastefully furnished and the kitchen is well equipped. The location is great for exploring the refuge. It‘s close to everything yet removed from the traffic noise. There is a very nice natural area in the back. In November,we didn‘t spend any time in the outside areas, which would be the only drawback for us in the warmer seasons. The very nice screened front porch overlooks driveways,cars and houses. The very small back deck overlooks what I believe to be sump pump etc.
In sum, the indoors and location are 5 stars. The outdoor area, while clean and tidy,could use some tlc.

The house was sparkling clean and very comfortable (it would be even more comfortable,if the owner replaced the plastic mattress coverings with a nicer material). It is very tastefully furnished and the kitchen is well equipped. The location is great for exploring the refuge. It‘s close to everything yet removed from the traffic noise. There is a very nice natural area in the back. In November,we didn‘t spend any time in the outside areas, which would be the only drawback for us in the warmer seasons. The very nice screened front porch overlooks driveways,cars and houses. The very small back deck overlooks what I believe to be sump pump etc.
In sum, the indoors and location are 5 stars. The outdoor area, while clean and tidy,could use some tlc.

Loved this cozy, extremely clean cottage. Situated in a very peaceful, woodsy area of Chincoteague. Comfortable beds, closets and well-equipped kitchen. Loved the screened porch for eating outside. We have been using Chincoteague Resort Vacations for years, their customer service is the best.

Manager's Response

We loved this house! Quiet section of Oyster Bay.

Property was clean and well and nicely appointed, and maintenance was on the spot! This is a bit dark but well screened from the myriad mosquitoes. There was no booklet found describing the full TV offerings or AC regulation which would have been helpful.

A total “WOW” moment from the second we opened the front door! Serenity delivered! The home was immaculate, well-appointed and classy. So many laughs were shared around the large table and it is truly the heart of this awesome home. Each room is spacious and comfortable yet somehow cozy! The master bedroom bed is fantastic and the shower was ideal after sunny beach days and early morning jogs/biking to burn off Sandy Pony and Whippys! Quiet mornings with coffee in the sun room were a daily fave! This house was absolutely exceptional!

This house was very clean and well stocked. It was a most relaxing and quiet week. We love the Oyster Bay Community.

Great escape from the city, perfect house for families. Quiet neighborhood, biking distance of the beach. Plenty of space for the kids to run around. Would come here again.

The home was beautiful with a lovely screen porch and sunroom. When we arrived, there was no water. The management company came within two hours. I was frustrated by the customer service I was given when booking and paying for the rental.

The home was beautiful with a lovely screen porch and sunroom. When we arrived, there was no water. The management company came within two hours. I was frustrated by the customer service I was given when booking and paying for the rental.

We had a wonderful time! Serenity at Oyster Bay is lovely house. It was very clean and well stocked. We hope to visit again!